Musings

I'm just copying my father

Home

Ms. Holmes and Ms. Watson Review

First Published: 2023 August 24

Draft 1

A few weeks ago now1 I did something that I haven’t done in a while.2 I went to go see a play. The university I attend3 was putting on a production of Ms. Holmes and Ms. Watson.

Now, if you’re anything like me, then your first instinct will be to complain that it’s “Ms.” Watson, not “Dr.” Watson.4 I had that complaint going in, especially since the play was described as a feminist retelling.5 I had6 recently subscribed to a SubStack7 called “Letters from Watson,” which just sends out serialized versions of the Sherlock Holmes short stories. It’s really interesting reading them, especially as someone who reads8 a fair amount of modern serialized fiction. The genre conventions have certainly shifted in the intervening years. However, since this post is a review of the show, rather than the fiction, I digress.

When I arrived, the play promised many of the common staples of modern small work plays. It said that there would be forced audience participation9 and that it was a loving but disrespectful10 retelling of Arthur Conan Doyle’s work. It was fine.

I’m not sure whether I was just hungry and so not as into the play as normal, but the play lacked a lot of flow to me. When I go to a play that I really enjoy, at least for a moment I forget that what I am watching is a play. At no point during the show did I forget that I was sitting in a crowd, watching a performance. I suppose the fourth wall breaks did add to that feeling.11 Still, it was an enjoyable show, and I would happily see it again.


  1. because wow it turns out that one reason I might stop posting is because I become suddenly busy

  2. though, given the infinite number of potential permutations of activities I can do, that’s not the most meaningful statement.

  3. which is such an awkward construction

  4. of course, that’s presupposing a lot about the (allegedly extant) readership of my blog, I suppose

  5. not to stereotype, but as one might expect by the gender swapping in the title.

  6. have?

  7. newsletter app, more or less

  8. and writes

  9. though it phrased it differently,

  10. again, me paraphrasing, I don’t remember the actual verbiage

  11. this is not the place for me to go into a rant about the way that I dislike modern (popular) media’s tendency (tendencies? media is technically inherently plural) to avoid any sort of genuine emotional appeal by hiding it behind sarcasm and smarm. There will be a place for it sometime soon, but not today

  12. which is shockingly hard for me to type. I had to erase four four four at least once (and then again when trying to type what my mistake was, I put for in the wrong place as well

  13. though indeterminate

  14. two verses, a bridge, and a chorus. It’s probably only like two or three minutes long, but that’s fine.